China’s burgeoning real estate sector recently faced an unexpected downturn in July, with new home prices dropping by a slight 0.2%, following a static June. This descent may seem insignificant on the surface, but it has serious underlying implications that could potentially ripple across multiple industries.
Understanding the Extent of the Fall
National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) tracks property prices in 70 cities across China. According to their data, only 20 cities reported a rise in new home prices in July, a significant reduction from the 31 cities that had an upward trend in June. More concerning is the trend in the second-hand market, where only six cities experienced a price increase, while the rest remained stagnant in June.
Fu Linghui, an NBS spokesman, remarked that the present scenario indicates a significant transition in the real estate market. Some leading real estate businesses are grappling with operational difficulties, driven in part by their increasing exposure to debt risks. This, in turn, has contributed to skewed market expectations.
Underlying Factors Impacting the Property Sector
Investments in real estate development, from January to July, plummeted by 8.5% YoY, amounting to an alarming 6.77 trillion yuan (roughly US$943.5 billion), based on NBS data. This situation was made worse by a 19% YoY fall in new home sales for July, maintaining the pace set in the preceding month. Major developers like Country Garden Holdings and China Vanke faced an even steeper decline, with sales plummeting by 60% and 35% YoY respectively.
The latest insights from JPMorgan anticipate a potential shrink in China’s residential property market, more than previously predicted. According to their projections, there could be a 10% contraction in the value of new home sales this year, as opposed to their earlier 4% decline prediction.
Country Garden’s recent failure in servicing coupon payments for two US dollar bonds has sparked anxieties surrounding its financial robustness. As T Rowe Price emphasized in a note, a potential default on the part of Country Garden could inadvertently harm other private property developers. Sheldon Chan, an expert in Asian credit bond strategy, suggests that state-affiliated developers might remain relatively insulated from such consequences.
Gary Ng from Natixis offers an even more encompassing view. He opines that the current economic issues in China are deeply structural in nature. He warns of a potential ripple effect, with sluggish home sales and Country Garden’s liquidity issues spilling over into other sectors, creating a risk of contagion.
Price Trends in Major Cities
In July, new home prices in prominent cities such as Shenzhen and Guangzhou declined by 0.6% and 0.2% MoM respectively. Contrastingly, prices in Beijing and Shanghai witnessed modest rises of 0.4% and 0.2% respectively.
Data from NBS also indicated a more pronounced fall in the secondary market. Prices in large to medium cities dipped anywhere between 1.4% to 3.5%. A note from US investment bank, Goldman Sachs, reiterated this trend. Their analysis suggested that new home prices in July declined by 2.5%, a significant jump from 2.2% in June.
Goldman Sachs pointed out that despite housing easing measures introduced recently, property markets, especially in lower-tier cities, confront challenges stemming from weaker growth fundamentals. Factors like net population outflows and potential oversupply issues further complicate the situation.
Governmental Measures and Their Impact
China’s central bank has expressed its commitment to guide commercial banks in reducing mortgage rates for existing borrowers and slashing down payments on properties. However, this wave of optimism post the Politburo meeting, which saw the removal of the statement “housing is for living, not speculation”, seems to have died down. The top leadership has not displayed any significant shift in their stance.
Fu from NBS remains optimistic. He believes that as market mechanisms gain more prominence and real estate policies are refined, these challenges faced by real estate companies will likely be overcome. Goldman, on the other hand, forecasts additional housing easing measures in the upcoming months. This includes further reductions in down payment ratios and relaxation of home purchase restrictions in large cities.
Yet, with an ongoing property weakness related to lower-tier cities and private developers, such easing measures might only set the stage for an ‘L-shaped’ recovery trajectory for the sector in the subsequent years.
T Rowe Price presents a more stringent perspective. Chan from T Rowe predicts a long-term structural downturn in China’s property sector. He attributes this to a combination of factors including a declining population, a slowdown in urbanization, and shifts in family formation patterns.
Conclusion
China’s real estate sector, once considered an unstoppable force, is now facing unanticipated challenges. These trends not only offer insights into the immediate state of the housing market but also hint at broader structural issues within the country’s economy. As various stakeholders – from developers and investors to policymakers and consumers – navigate this evolving landscape, the world will be watching closely. The outcomes in China’s property market could have profound implications for global economic dynamics in the years to come.
Read More: