In a case that has shone a spotlight on the complexities of domestic abuse litigation in China, a 23-year-old woman from Beijing, known by the pseudonym Xiaogu, found her legal pursuit for justice against her mother’s long-term abuse thwarted by judicial obstacles. Xiaogu’s story, which has been widely discussed in the media, reveals the nuances and difficulties in legally addressing domestic violence in China, particularly in the context of mental health.
Xiaogu’s struggle began in her childhood, marked by constant physical and verbal abuse from her mother, a situation that once escalated to the point of hospitalization. In 2019, she was diagnosed with depression and sleep disorders, conditions she attributed to the cumulative impact of her mother’s abuse. Her efforts to seek legal redress, however, faced significant hurdles. In 2021, after enduring another episode of mistreatment, Xiaogu moved to a youth hostel and initiated legal action against her mother for violating her rights to life, body, and health.
During an online trial in April of the previous year, Xiaogu presented various forms of evidence, including 43 awards from her past, medical records, photographs of her injuries, and recordings of her mother’s verbal abuse. Despite her efforts, the court dismissed her lawsuit on two grounds: the lack of concrete evidence of abuse and the absence of a proven causal link between her mental health conditions and the conflicts with her mother. The court, however, granted Xiaogu a domestic violence restraining order, barring her mother from further physical or threatening behavior.
After the trial, Xiaogu returned to live with her mother, deliberately minimizing contact with her. She has since emerged as an online influencer, advocating against domestic violence and offering support to others facing similar parental abuse. Her experiences underline the enduring pain and challenges in overcoming such deep-seated trauma.
Legal experts in China have noted the particular difficulty in obtaining evidence for mental abuse cases. The first national Anti-Domestic Violence Law, enacted in 2016, included mental abuse within its purview, acknowledging its severe impact. Yet, as Gao Lei, Deputy Director of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm’s women’s legal aid center, points out, the intangible nature of verbal abuse makes judicial proof particularly challenging, leaving many victims without legal recourse.
Xiaogu’s case, and the online survey indicating widespread acceptance of corporal punishment, reflects a larger societal issue in China regarding the recognition and handling of domestic abuse, especially involving children. Her story has sparked a broader dialogue on the need for more robust legal frameworks and societal awareness to protect the vulnerable from domestic violence in all its forms.
READ MORE: