Recent events in China’s financial markets have presented a conundrum for investors and policymakers alike. Expectations had surged following hints of prospective reforms and policies aimed at bolstering China’s capital markets. However, with hopes waning and the market’s momentum slowing, there are growing concerns regarding the tangible steps to be taken. This article delves into the nuances and intricacies of the situation, providing a comprehensive overview of what has transpired and its implications for the future.
The Politburo Catalyst
On July 24, China’s top decision-making body, the Politburo, held a meeting, which, albeit unexpectedly, kindled widespread speculations in the financial sector. The rare mention of intentions to rejuvenate the capital market spurred anticipations of two key reforms: a reduction in the stamp duty on stocks and the re-establishment of a system permitting the purchase and sale of stocks on the same day.
These expectations were not baseless. Reduction in stamp duty could significantly stimulate trading by making it more affordable, while the reintroduction of a same-day trading mechanism would give investors more flexibility, aligning the Chinese markets more closely with global standards.
However, much to the market’s chagrin, these high expectations were not met. There were some changes, albeit minor ones. The Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges proposed a reduction in the minimum bid quantity for shares and promised to enhance regulatory oversight.
Market Response: A Mix of Discontent and Skepticism
The market’s reaction was swift and telling. The adjustments, though well-intended, were deemed insufficient to satisfy investors. Brokerages, expected to be the primary beneficiaries of any capital-market reforms, began showing indications of unwinding positions.
This sentiment is well captured by an index by Shanghai DZH, which monitors 54 listed brokerages, including industry stalwarts like Citic Securities and China International Capital. This index registered a drop of 2% from its peak in August.
Dai Ming, a seasoned fund manager at Huichen Asset Management in Shanghai, expressed a sentiment echoed by many, “While verbal assurances used to suffice when the stock market was a smaller fraction of China’s economy, they’re no longer enough given the market’s current size. Concrete and impactful actions are the need of the hour.”
The Chinese Stock Market: A Brief Overview
China boasts the second-largest stock market globally, with a valuation that has multiplied by a staggering 25 times in just two decades, standing at a monumental US$9.9 trillion. However, this growth narrative has encountered a stumbling block this year. Despite its size, the market has remained largely stagnant, lagging behind other prominent Asian markets such as Japan and South Korea. This stagnation is attributed to the slowdown in post-Covid growth and the perceived insufficiency of government’s stimulative measures.
T+0 and Stamp Duty: A Closer Look
One of the primary demands of investors has been the reintroduction of the T+0 trading system. This system, which was operational in the early stages of China’s stock markets, allows for the buying and selling of stocks on the same day. This was replaced in 1992 by the T+1 system, where stocks bought can only be sold the next day. The shift was a measure to deter speculative trading. However, this system has since been a bone of contention among investors, primarily those looking to capitalize quickly on market developments.
It’s worth noting that most global markets, including nearby Hong Kong, operate without such trading constraints, making the Chinese market an outlier.
Additionally, investors have clamored for a reduction in the stamp duty for stock transactions. The last time this duty was reduced, from 0.3% to 0.1% in April 2008, it triggered a significant market rally, with the CSCI 300 Index registering a 9.3% gain in a single day. A similar surge was observed later that year when the tax on stock sales was completely abolished.
Challenges and Roadblocks
However, the path to these reforms is fraught with challenges. The government’s fiscal revenues have been under pressure, particularly due to declining land sales and an underperforming stock market. Data reveals that revenues from the stamp duty on stock transactions in the first half of the year plummeted by 31%, amounting to 110.8 billion yuan (approximately US$15.2 billion). This decline might deter policymakers from further tax reductions.
Looking Ahead: A Pivotal Juncture
As Dai Ming of Huichen Asset aptly puts it, “If forceful measures aren’t enacted, the market could break some crucial technical thresholds, potentially triggering accelerated sell-offs. This could escalate into a major issue.”
The current sentiment suggests a crucial inflection point for China’s capital markets. While hopes were ignited by the Politburo meeting, they have since dimmed due to the lack of substantial action. The ball is now in the court of regulators and policymakers to navigate the way forward, with the stakes higher than ever.
Read More: