Mimi Monica Wong, the head of HSBC’s private banking in Asia, has successfully sued her Latin dance instructors for the return of HK$62 million (US$8 million) in prepaid fees following an incident where one instructor insulted her in public. Wong’s lawsuit and its resolution have captured significant attention.
Wong testified in the Court of First Instance that she had been deeply enthusiastic about her Latin dance lessons, which were initially scheduled for six lessons a day, seven days a week. She pursued these lessons passionately, seeking what she described as “the last bit of glory in life.” However, her relationship with her dance instructor, Mirko Saccani, began to deteriorate in 2002 when he pressured her to prepay increasing amounts of money. They agreed on a fee of HK$120 million for eight years of unlimited dance lessons and competitions, with Saccani serving as her dancing partner and instructor.
The turning point occurred on August 25, 2004, during a practice session at Li Hua Restaurant in Causeway Bay. Wong recounted how Saccani insulted her in front of a crowd, telling her to “move your a***” and calling her a “lazy cow.” This public humiliation led Wong to seek legal recourse.
On September 7, 2006, the court ruled in favor of Wong, ordering her former Latin dance teachers to refund her HK$62 million in prepaid fees. Deputy Judge Gerard Muttrie of the Court of First Instance concluded that Saccani had breached the “mutual trust and confidence” essential to their agreement through his derogatory treatment of Wong.
Further proceedings on November 24, 2006, addressed the interest payment on the refunded amount. The court decided to halve the interest payment initially requested, awarding Wong HK$4.6 million in interest in addition to the fee refund.
Wong’s case highlights the importance of maintaining professional conduct and trust in personal service agreements. The substantial refund and interest payment underscore the court’s recognition of the breach of trust and the emotional impact of the public insult Wong endured. This legal victory not only compensates Wong for her financial loss but also serves as a reminder of the standards of respect and professionalism expected in all professional relationships.
READ MORE: