In recent events, the stocks of German automakers had a noticeable impact on Europe’s auto index. The underlying cause was the mounting concerns about potential retaliation from Beijing. Should the European Union (EU) impose tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles (EVs), German automakers are feared to bear the brunt of the backlash. But what leads to these apprehensions, and how is the broader European auto market reacting?
The EU-China Trade Dynamics
Europe has shown indications of considering tariffs on imported Chinese electric vehicles. Such measures often stem from a combination of factors including trade imbalances, concerns over unfair competition, or the simple dynamics of global politics. In this instance, Beijing did not react favorably. It condemned the prospective probe into its EV exports, branding it as a protectionist move. China has cautioned that such a move would strain the economic ties between the two global powers.
Amidst this tug of war, there’s a looming fear: China might establish its own trade barriers. If realized, this could detrimentally limit the export of German cars to China. The irony is that German car exports to China are already witnessing a decline.
A Potential Game Changer for Chinese EV Makers in Europe?
With the EU mulling over punitive tariffs on Chinese imports, analysts posit another angle to the story. Such tariffs could, in fact, expedite Chinese EV manufacturers‘ intentions to set up shop within Europe. The implications? An intensified competition for local European automakers.
China’s EV production industry has several competitive advantages. Fueled by government subsidies, easy access to raw materials, and significant technological advancements from early EV investments, Chinese EV manufacturers enjoy a production cost that’s significantly lower than their Western rivals. However, despite these advantages, when these EVs land on European shores, they’re priced higher than they are back home. The reasons for this markup range from additional costs like shipping to local customization and configuration.
France’s Stance on the EU-China Trade Dynamics
The President of France, Emmanuel Macron, has been vocally critical about the EU’s approach toward trade with nations like China. His argument rests on the notion that the EU ought to stop its naive approach and demand equal trading grounds with global powerhouses. Consequently, France has been nudging the European Commission, albeit covertly, to greenlight the probe into Chinese EV imports.
A source from the French finance ministry emphasized the need for instruments to counter subsidies. In their words, the time to deploy such tools is now.
The Terrain of Intense Competition
The ripples of this prospective trade standoff are felt deeply within the European auto industry’s corridors. Leading voices, including the CEOs of Renault and Stellantis, have sounded the alarm. Their companies, dominant in the European mass-market model segment yet having a minimal footprint in China, are increasingly wary of the surging competition from Chinese brands.
In a contrasting stance, German automakers, who depend on China for approximately a third of their passenger car sales, have been circumspect. The stakes for them are indeed higher, and their cautious approach reflects their dependencies.
Companies like Volkswagen and BMW opted for silence when probed for comments. Mercedes-Benz, on the other hand, voiced its advocacy for “liberal trade regulation grounded in WTO rules.” The luxury carmaker further emphasized its belief that protectionist strategies are invariably counterproductive.
Daniel Roeska, an analyst from Bernstein, offered a perspective in a research note. He posited that Renault and Stellantis could emerge as the beneficiaries in this scenario. With reduced mass-market competition and no immediate threat from potential Chinese counteractions, they stand in a favorable position. Volkswagen, despite the prospect of reduced competition, remains vulnerable. Premium original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) grapple with the threat of Chinese retaliation. For them, the road ahead, especially their China-centric export strategies, appears uncertain.
Stock Market Reactions
The repercussions of these trade dynamics were palpable in the stock market. By 1210 GMT, the STOXX Europe 600 Auto index had slumped by 1.46%. In comparison, the broader market held its ground. Specific automakers felt the pinch distinctly:
- Porsche, for whom China is the primary market, witnessed a stock price dip of 2.95%.
- BMW, with plans of exporting its iX3 from China and eyeing Mini exports by 2024, saw a decrease of 2.08%.
- Mercedes-Benz and Volkswagen experienced declines of 1.56% and 1.83% respectively.
However, Renault and Stellantis, both of which have a lesser stake in the Chinese market compared to their German peers, had milder stock reductions, registering at 1.33% and 0.81% respectively.
In Conclusion
The unfolding dynamics between the EU and China around the auto industry offers a glimpse into the complexities of global trade in the modern era. With economic, political, and technological factors all interplaying, stakeholders, from governments to businesses, are in a constant balancing act. For now, the world watches closely, awaiting the next moves from both sides.
Read More: