At the recent United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), President Joe Biden’s address steered the spotlight onto the ongoing Ukraine crisis, eliciting mixed responses from global leaders and experts. While the UNGA’s central theme for the year was “rebuilding trust and reigniting global solidarity,” Biden’s emphasis on the Ukraine issue seemed to overshadow the gathering’s primary focus.
Biden’s Address: Leadership and Crisis
Biden used the UNGA platform to underscore US “leadership” in the global arena. The central point of his address was the urgency of the Ukraine crisis, turning it into the primary topic of discussion and debate. He argued for sustained international support for Ukraine, emphasizing the consequences of a world that grows weary of Russia’s prolonged conflict in Kiev. According to Biden, diminishing support for Ukraine could give Russia the leeway to act against the country without facing significant repercussions.
He stressed the significance of global unity, suggesting that the security of nations could be at stake if “we allow Ukraine to be carved up.” This message was clear: the world must remain united in defending Ukraine against Russia.
China’s Perspective: Mixed Responses
Chinese experts have been vocal about their views on Biden’s UNGA address. They argue that Biden’s emphasis on the Ukraine issue reveals Washington’s diminished interest in the growth and challenges faced by the Global South. This perceived oversight might not bode well for the US’s relations with developing nations.
Furthermore, while Biden’s speech included remarks on the China-US relationship, emphasizing the need for “responsible management of competition” to prevent conflict, Chinese experts are not entirely convinced. To them, the words hint at the White House’s uncertainty in navigating the world’s arguably most crucial bilateral relationship. They see it as indicative of a pattern where the US often expresses intentions that don’t always translate into actions, casting doubt on Washington’s commitment to genuinely improving ties with Beijing.
Russia-Ukraine Crisis Takes Center Stage
The Russia-Ukraine conflict undoubtedly played a dominant role in this year’s UNGA, despite other pressing global concerns. By centering on this issue, the US effectively consolidated its alliances and used the crisis to critique and exert pressure on other countries. The strategy, according to Professor Li Haidong from the China Foreign Affairs University, is a hijacking of the UNGA’s intended purpose, molding it into a tool that advances US geopolitical aims.
Additionally, there were reports suggesting Biden’s intention to urge the UN to restructure the Security Council. The proposed expansion would include countries like Germany and Japan, potentially minimizing the influence of China and Russia.
European Council President Charles Michel also weighed in on the matter. A draft of his speech, accessed by Reuters, revealed plans to directly request China’s assistance at the United Nations Security Council to push Russia toward a “just peace” in Ukraine.
Biden’s Gaffe: A Momentary Slip?
In a circulated video, Biden misspoke during his address, confusing the UN with the US. He mistakenly said, “If we abandon the core principles of the US (intending to say ‘UN Charter’), to appease an aggressor…” While some might dismiss it as a minor slip, others see it as a reflection of the US’s blurred vision and priorities.
Li reiterated the importance of recognizing the immediate concerns of developing countries. For many of these nations, the Ukraine issue, though undeniably critical, might not be their primary concern. They look to the UNGA for solutions to their developmental challenges. By redirecting the UNGA’s focus, the US might inadvertently be alienating the Global South, fostering feelings of discontent and resentment.
A Call for Peace and Diplomacy
Amid the politically charged atmosphere, Dennis Francis, president of the 78th session of the UN General Assembly, made a significant statement. Presiding over the UNGA’s opening debate, Francis reminded member states of the event’s core mission. He emphasized the necessity of using the platform for promoting dialogue and diplomacy rather than fanning the flames of conflict. His words were a poignant reminder: “Peace is an investment in our collective prosperity.”
The SDG Summit and US Global Leadership: A Critical Overview
The recent Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) Summit, convened alongside the General Debate, was an opportunity for global leaders to take stock of progress made towards these pivotal goals. Francis, the event’s coordinator, pointed out that while there had been advancements, the pace was concerning. Delays and regressions have been all too prevalent, emphasizing an immediate need for substantial progress.
Biden’s Address and Global South Development
President Joe Biden’s speech at the Summit has garnered mixed reactions. While he highlighted US global leadership, many felt he fell short in addressing the developmental needs of the Global South. Instead of presenting concrete plans or solutions, Biden’s address emphasized the collective need for more action concerning the SDGs.
Lü Xiang, a research fellow specializing in US studies at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, found Biden’s remarks lacking in depth and commitment. To Lü, the speech felt insubstantial, evidenced by the fact that the only significant applause Biden received was when discussing the defense of Ukraine. This emphasis raises concerns regarding the US’s engagement and interest in Global South issues.
US-China Relations: Climate Change at the Forefront
During his address, Biden touched upon the US-China relationship, stating, “We seek to responsibly manage competition between our countries so it doesn’t escalate to conflict.” He emphasized the mutual aspiration of de-risking the relationship rather than creating a more significant divide.
A central theme of Biden’s commentary on China was climate change – an issue where both nations have found common ground. Highlighting recent environmental disasters worldwide, Biden painted a vivid picture of the future if the dependence on fossil fuels continues. He made a compelling case for a united effort in combating these challenges and climate-proofing the world.
Parallel to Biden’s address, a meeting took place between US Special Presidential Envoy for Climate, John Kerry, and Chinese Vice President Han Zheng. Han Zheng reinforced China’s unwavering commitment to achieving peak carbon emissions and transitioning to carbon neutrality. He emphasized the importance of continued dialogue and collaboration between the two nations on this front, stating that it holds significance not just bilaterally but for the entire world. Han asserted that China is eager to deepen its ties with the US in advancing climate governance, which he believes will immensely benefit human development.
Lü Xiang observed that while Biden’s mention of China was brief, it prominently featured climate change – showcasing the area of cooperation between the two giants. Lü felt that the US’s diplomatic wording was cautious when referencing China-US ties. He commented on the current state of US-China relations, suggesting that the US finds itself in a precarious situation. With limited options at their disposal, US leaders are grappling with the challenge of managing this crucial relationship. Lü believes there exists a discrepancy between US words and actions, and it remains to be seen if the US will take concrete steps to enhance its ties with China. While a “window of opportunity” still exists for bilateral relations, the path forward remains uncertain.
Strengthening US-China Diplomatic Relations
Prior to Biden’s speech, a series of diplomatic meetings set the tone for future US-China relations. US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Chinese Vice President Han met on the UNGA sidelines, where Han reiterated that a stable US-China relationship is in the best interests of both nations and the world.
Furthermore, a significant meeting took place in Malta between Wang Yi, director of the Office of the Foreign Affairs Commission of the Communist Party of China Central Committee, and US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan. This meeting emphasized the continued commitment to uphold the consensus reached by the leaders of both countries during their Bali meeting. The consensus revolves around maintaining high-level dialogues and taking steps to stabilize and bolster US-China relations.
Conclusion
As the world grapples with challenges like sustainable development and climate change, the roles of global superpowers like the US and China are pivotal. The recent UNGA meetings and the SDG Summit have shone a light on the complexities of global leadership and bilateral relationships. The overarching sentiment is that while diplomatic speeches are significant, actions will ultimately shape the trajectory of global development and international relations. The world watches with bated breath as these superpowers navigate their path forward, hoping for collaboration over conflict and sustainable solutions over short-term fixes.
Read More: