The allure of the Japanese market for foreign retailers is both compelling and intricate. It promises lucrative returns yet poses inherent challenges, shaped by a mix of cultural, regulatory, and market idiosyncrasies. While many international brands have faced setbacks in their initial forays, some, learning from their missteps, have managed to make impressive comebacks.
High-profile Exits and Comebacks
Prominent retailers like Walmart, Ikea, and American Eagle Outfitters once exited Japan, unable to bridge cultural divides. However, Ikea and American Eagle’s reentries underscore the idea that with reflection and strategy recalibration, success in Japan is attainable.
Fashion stands out as a particularly ripe sector for foreign brands, given Japanese consumers‘ inclinations. Powerhouses such as Shein, H&M, Gap, and LightInTheBox have solid presences, with many others weighing their entry options between physical stores, e-commerce, or a blend of the two.
The Domestic Challenge
Michael Causton, a Japanese retail and marketing expert from JapanConsuming, points to the pattern of local support for domestic brands, such as when foreign firms make inroads. Be it Fast Retailing’s push following Gap’s 1994 entry or Nitori’s growth as Ikea made its return in 2006, domestic entities have always had formidable backing.
Crucially, while no overt barriers prevent foreign brands from entering, there’s a tacit favoring of domestic firms. Though Japan’s native textile manufacturing is on the wane, local fast fashion brands remain strong contenders, explains Causton.
Natalie Meyer, CEO of the market research firm Tokyoesque, posits that perceptions matter. Western brands, while falling under the ‘fast fashion’ bracket, convey a certain ‘cool’, contrasting starkly with local offerings prized for customization options. The competition is essentially with established local brands known for affordability and trendiness, such as those from Harajuku.
For Meyer, it’s strategic for foreign brands to position themselves with a touch of luxury, despite their fast fashion roots.
Common Pitfalls and Building Genuine Partnerships
Foreign brands need to be wary of the initial allure of a Japanese partnership, advises Meyer. Such associations can sometimes lead to a lack of control over expansion plans. The importance of finding the right partner aligning with a brand’s vision cannot be understated.
Building trustworthy partnerships demands an understanding of Japanese business culture and significant face-to-face interaction. Meyer elaborates, “It’s pivotal to show your partners trust, but equally crucial to have done your own market groundwork.”
It’s about aligning ambitions. Brands need to vet potential partners’ sales channels thoroughly, be it through departmental stores, online platforms, or pop-ups. Meyer cites the example of Forever 21, which, after its initial 2009 setback, collaborated with Itochu, indicating that partnerships with trading companies might be the key.
Yet, Causton counters with a preference for direct market entry. Drawing upon the successes of Louis Vuitton, Gap, Zara, and H&M, he points out how direct control, even in luxury sectors, often outperforms franchise models. A slew of brands like Topshop and American Eagle, among others, have been less successful due to unsuitable partnerships.
Aeon’s history, Causton remarks, is dotted with unsuccessful ventures with international brands. A fresh approach is now noticeable, focusing on a mix of limited physical stores and e-commerce, as Fast Retailing practices in Europe. This approach requires less capital and yields better profit margins.
Regulatory Complexities and Environmental Concerns
New government policies add further intricacies. Reports from the ministry underscore the growing geopolitical risks and their repercussions on global supply chains, inflation rates, and domestic investments. A rising concern about fast fashion’s environmental toll might also usher in new regulations.
Kiyoshi Okamura, from Japan’s Professional Institute of International Fashion, expresses concerns over the sustainability of the fast fashion model. He points to the global discourse on the environmental damage of mass production and how this resonates increasingly with Japan’s youth.
Demographics and Future Prospects
Another challenge, perhaps more stubborn, is the impending market shrinkage due to Japan’s declining population, warns Okamura.
Yet, despite these hurdles, the Japanese market remains ripe for foreign entities that can foster strong ties with government bodies, logistic companies, and local partners. Securing prime retail locations and influential advertisers can further tilt the scales. Moreover, brands that invest in Japanese manufacturing might find favor both with the authorities and discerning consumers.
Read More: