Residents of Carlsbad, California, living in apartments, condominiums, and townhouses will soon face restrictions on smoking inside their homes, as the city becomes the first in San Diego County to ban smoking and vaping of cannabis and nicotine products in all local multifamily residential buildings.
The new ordinance, which takes effect in January, has sparked debate within the community. While some residents view the ban as an unwelcome intrusion into their private lives, others applaud the decision, seeing it as a necessary step to protect the health of non-smokers exposed to second-hand smoke. Proponents of the ban highlight the significant health risks associated with second-hand smoke, which federal health officials warn can lead to heart disease, stroke, and lung cancer. According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, cigarette smoking is the leading cause of preventable death in the country, claiming more than 480,000 lives annually.
The ordinance prohibits smoking not only inside private residences within multifamily buildings but also on private balconies, porches, decks, patios, and common areas, except in designated smoking locations. Single-family homes, however, are exempt from the law.
The city’s move follows in the footsteps of at least 84 other California municipalities, including Beverly Hills, Culver City, and Pasadena, which have implemented similar bans in multifamily residences. Mayor Keith Blackburn expressed that the new law would provide property managers with a stronger tool to enforce non-smoking policies already present in many leases. He acknowledged that, in the past, property managers often hesitated to confront tenants about smoking due to the difficulty of enforcement.
“A lot of times managers don’t want to get into a confrontation because it’s just a policy or it’s just in the lease,” Blackburn explained during a council meeting in August 2023. “At least for the managers, we’re going to give them a tool.”
However, the ordinance has not been without its critics. Council member Melanie Burkholder, who cast the sole vote against the ban, voiced concerns about the role of local government in regulating personal behavior within private homes. Similarly, Will Creagan, chairman of Southwest Equity Partners, a local property management company, criticized the law as an example of government overreach. In a letter to city staff, Creagan questioned the practicality of expecting property managers to enforce the new rules.
To address concerns about enforcement, the city has stated that police and code enforcement officers will not be tasked with monitoring compliance. Instead, the responsibility will fall to landlords and other tenants, who will have the option to take legal action against violators.
As Carlsbad’s new smoking ban prepares to take effect, the ordinance stands as a significant step toward prioritizing public health and addressing the concerns of residents affected by second-hand smoke in multifamily housing.
READ MORE: